SYTYCD Australia Season 3: Top 14 Performance Show
Posted by chellekat on March 9, 2010

The top 14 performed last night with Kelley Abbey as guest judge.

The boys opened the show with a group routine to 'Cool' from West Side Story. The judges said unfortunately it “lacked intensity” and the “intention didn’t quite get there” for Kelley, but Matt “loved the unison”. Jason was very disappointed with it, as West Side Story is his “favourite musical”, and he thought their intensity was “not even close”. He felt the dancers must learn the steps “with intention” if they want to master the whole performance. I tend to agree with Jason on this one, I wasn't disappointed though as I didn't have high expectations.



Issi & Don were up next with Fabio Robles’s Street Latin routine. With Don receiving comments about his dancing sitting in front of the beat all the time, he took the time to chat with Matt backstage and get some tips during the week on how to fix the problem. The judges commended him for his growth and felt he really had improved and this was the best he has been so far. Matt thought the performance was “a bit clunky” when it needed to be seamless, but felt it was “the best” Don had done at sticking in the middle of the beat. For me, the routine lacked any real chemistry or passion. I agreed with Kelley when she said it didn't have any vitality or spark. I think there were some awkward moments in the dancing but overall it was much better than last week. They were very lucky to get Street Latin I think.



Heath & Jessica P had a Paul Malek Contemporary routine next. The judges thought the performance was passionate, Heath was a “caring partner” and Bonnie gave Jessica a “growth badge”. Jason felt she had done “better then any other ballroom dancer” in the past and commended her on having the most “incredible journey” of growth on the show. Matt “loved it so much” because he believed the performance and Kelley thought it was their “best routine so far”. I agree with the judges here, I thought Heath was especially great in his own genre and I really bought into the story - the darkness and the struggle between them. It was very intense and I couldn't take my eyes off them. This would be one of my favourites of the night.



Robbie & Ivy were up next with a Jason Gilkison Paso Doble. Jason “knew” they were going to come out and “own that” and commended them for another stand out performance, pointing out Robbie’s “intensity” and Ivy’s screen presence. Kelly felt the couple “really were popping” and believed Ivy was a good actress in her dancing, which she had also brought out in Robbie. In a great moment for Robbie, Matt said “You started as a boy, you just became a man” and it was “the first time” Matt has been on the edge of his seat in the competition. I thought the routine was perfect for them and Jason had really worked hard to make sure it would be the right fit for them (right down to the little wardrobe adjustments to make Robbie appear taller). I think because Jason understood both of their personalities he was able to mould the routine around them. I believed the passion in the routine, for me Ivy was actually the stand out because she's so sexy and the camera loves her so much. I didn't love it as much as the audience but I thought it was great overall. I especially enjoyed the beginning and the end.



Kieran & Carly had a Debbie Ellis Contemporary routine about lovers being torn apart by their families. Matt “loved the unison” and thought they “absolutely nailed it”. Jason thought it was Carly’s best work in the competition and loved her in it. He felt they were showing “exactly what this competition” was about - growth. I basically agree with everything the judges said. As a couple, these two have just been on fire and they obviously have so much trust which is really evident in the lifts which are so effortless. I think this would be the one time I can say they were both great - usually I say Kieran is better but I think they both matched beautifully here. This would be one of the other routines of the night for me.



Matt & Jessie H. performed a Square Division Jazz routine next. From the rehearsal video it was obvious Matt had a stressful lead up to the routine, unsure of where to focus his efforts to grow himself in this competition. He felt the judges had not given him clear critique about how to move forward. Matt Lee thought Jessie H. tended to out dance Matt, but believed tonight he had kept up well. In a humble moment Jason admitted he had given them “bad adjudication” last week and was keen to make up for it with his praise for a routine he thought was “the best they had done” in the competition. Kelly thought “it really needed to hit hard and it did.”, but felt Matt needed to push his boundaries to keep up with Jessie. I enjoyed this much more than I thought I would - while I'll admit I can't wait to see them perform a contemporary piece where Jessie in particular can really shine, I must say that these two are my power couple at the moment because they have this ease between them when it comes to chemistry so they just bounce off each other with the comedy of two of the routines they've had. I think they both matched each other evenly here and as a couple I think they were the most cohesive (just behind Carly and Keiran). This was one of my other favourites of the night.



Phillipe & Renee were next with a Waltz by Leanne Bampton about two strangers meeting in the rain. Jason thought they didn’t pull off the effortlessness of the Waltz, but “Loved the way” Phillipe looked at Renee throughout the performance. But Matt thought the performance was not “going to be memorable” and they would be forgotten in the highs of the other routines. This routine really fell flat for me, I felt like Phillipe was better than Renee here and a little more relaxed. There were a few moments where I thought they connected well facially (especially the little smile from Phillipe) and I think they have chemistry but it didn't work here. My main issue is a little strange but I couldn't stand the outfit they put Renee in - I felt as if they should have put her in a beautiful floaty dress and it would add more to the piece, it sort of made her look a bit awkward (for me anyway).



Nick & Jess S. had Hip Hop with Tiana. In the rehearsal clip Nick appeared to be struggling, not only with the fact that he'd lost two partners and he didn't know when he'd lose his next (or would be next to go himself) but also with the choreography. The old school Hip Hop routine really pushed them both to their limits, but Nick in particular had a lot of trouble with the steps. Jason felt the “biggest issue” was with the unison, Kelly “loved the old school flavour” but felt Nick “struggled” with it. Jason felt the same, thinking they didn’t “spend enough time making it clean”. Jess revealed that she was finding the criticism really hard to take each week and she had never experienced anything like it before as a dancer. Nick admitted that he was struggling hard with the routine, and was unable to get some of the big steps. Kelly advised them to “take that criticism and make it constructive”. This routine just didn't work for me which is really unfortunate as I think Nick and Jess have the potential to be a real power couple - both being among my favourites and they're just so hot together! I think the routine was just too hard for them to pull off. Jess obviously fared much better than Nick here. I really hope they both pull through, I know I'll be voting.



The girls group routine was the 'Cell Block Tango' from Chicago. Jason “Loved the finish” but felt the small amount of dancing wasn’t clean enough. Matt felt they were “all strong and committed” but felt they weren’t in control of their props. Kelley was left wanting, not believing the murderous intent of the characters that she expected from the routine. For me, Jess, Ivy and Jessie stood out but I agree there was a lack of unison.

Bookmark and Share
Comments

Post a Comment
Total Comments: 12
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 1:04:00 AM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
Have fun, chellekat! I read some spoilers and it doesn't sound promising.


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: chellekat on March 10, 2010 1:40:54 AM ETPost link
Staff


Gender: Female
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 224
Favs: Talia F, Janette M, Kate W, Pania T
Thank you! Yes I read those too. Well I'm hoping it'll be better than expected.


SYTYCDA3: Jessie H, Nick, Heath, Matt, Ivy
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 1:47:52 AM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
I think we are at the point now where I will just have accept that this season will not be as good as last season.


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 1:16:04 PM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
They opened the phone lines at the top of the show? That's kind of unfair, isn't it?


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: chellekat on March 10, 2010 6:26:38 PM ETPost link
Staff


Gender: Female
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 224
Favs: Talia F, Janette M, Kate W, Pania T
I think so too unfortunately. I'm still enjoying this season though and I think overall we have a great group of dancers. But it's hard to top season 2 for me right now.

They opened the phone lines at the start of the show?? That's just wrong. They did this during Idol last year (which is being 'rested' this year, probably going to be cancelled)... it always worries me when they go down that path...

Just watching the show now and writing a recap as I go.


SYTYCDA3: Jessie H, Nick, Heath, Matt, Ivy
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 6:49:53 PM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
My guess is that they are not getting as many votes as they'd like so they opened the phone lines early. If they want to get votes, they're going have to put on a better show. People are not going to be motivated to vote (especially if they have to pay for it) if you don't give them something to get excited about. I'm going to go watch now also. I'm going to try and post a download link soon.


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 8:18:51 PM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
Haha... now I feel like my last post was kind of harsh cause I thought it was a pretty good show. I loved the Carly & Kieran Contemporary and thought the Jessie & Matt Jazz was great too.

I loved the choreography in Jess & Nick's routine but I don't think they nailed it. I think if they had a little more time they probably would have nailed it and it would have been great.

Jessica & Heath were good.

Robbie & Ivy had a great performance also, but I think they really got by on their performances.

I thought Issi & Don's Ballroom/Hip-Hop or whatever wasn't terrible.

I thought Phillipe's knees were supposed to be bent. But anyway, I thought he did a good job. Maybe he could have been a bit smoother. I didn't like Renee in this at all.


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: chellekat on March 10, 2010 9:04:48 PM ETPost link
Staff


Gender: Female
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 224
Favs: Talia F, Janette M, Kate W, Pania T
I agree, it definitely wasn't as bad as expected! In fact, I've had trouble picking my favourite routine of the night! It's a tie for me between Carly/Kieran, Jessie/Matt and Jessica/Heath. I will admit though Jessie/Matt are my sentimental faves right now as a couple as they just nail everything that's thrown at them - there's this really easy chemistry they have going and are able to keep a realistic comedic performance going which isn't easy. I think they both bring out the best in eachothers personality too.

I thought Robbie and Ivy were good but not as great as the crowd and judges thought. Ivy actually stood out for me more here, she's just got that sizzling intensity that makes you watch every move. Robbie surprised me though as he did pull off a masculine performance here. I think they were very lucky to get JG as he works with the dancers and figures out what will bring out both of their strengths.

I didn't enjoy the Don/Issi hip hop but it wasn't anywhere near as bad as last week.

I completely agree with you on Renee and Phillipe as you'll see above. I didn't like her, I really liked him. I pictured him with a different partner here actually. I think Renee really needs to relax - she really peaks in her own style last last week but really loses her confidence in anything else. I don't know if it would have improved anything if she had been wearing a different dress but for me that just added to everything - I like my waltzes to be floaty and she seemed heavy.


SYTYCDA3: Jessie H, Nick, Heath, Matt, Ivy
Posted by: nobody on March 10, 2010 9:20:25 PM ETPost link
Site Admin


Gender: Male
Location: Canada
Posts: 1193
Favs: Allison H, Talia F, Kathryn M, Janette M
I was gonna say that I thought Renee's dress made her look like an old lady.

Top 14 ep - Download from Gigasize

Btw, did you remove your sig cause I made it show in the comments? Do you want me to put it back the way it was?


<3 Carrie Underwood | Allison Holker | Talia Fowler | Kathryn McCormick <3
SYTYCD S7: Ashley, Lauren, Alex, Billy, Kent, Melinda
Posted by: chellekat on March 10, 2010 9:33:06 PM ETPost link
Staff


Gender: Female
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 224
Favs: Talia F, Janette M, Kate W, Pania T
That's it exactly, it made her look like an old lady. Renee has a strong body, but the dress just made her look all wrong imo. She needed something flattering.

lol no I'm just in the middle of changing my sig over to some new pics I like from this season. I love my old pics but thought it was time for a change. Also thought my faves should be listed as a few have changed around.


SYTYCDA3: Jessie H, Nick, Heath, Matt, Ivy
Posted by: jack on March 11, 2010 5:52:54 AM ETPost link
both the boys and girls routines have been performed before and were executed quite well. was it the UK version, or the states? it may be hard to measure up to the movie versions of either or the previous performances. as i live in the states i shall have to wait a bit to see it.
Posted by: Anonymous on March 11, 2010 6:06:03 AM ETPost link
here's the UK version...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kDxm19pHX8&NR=1

there is also footage of an audition stage version from the US
Total Comments: 12
Post a Comment

Home | Forum | Bios / Previous Seasons | Videos / Performances | News Archive | Affiliates | Contact Us
Top